Teethers & Pacifiers

Our collection of non-toxic teethers and natural pacifiers are free of phthalates, vinyls, and plastics. Instead, we’ve selected pacifiers and teethers made of natural materials such as rubber, silicone, wood, and organic cotton.

  • Hevea Rubber Panda Teether from Gimme the Good Stuff

    Hevea Natural Rubber Teether – Panda

    $12.99
    Quick View
  • Hevea Natural Rubber Pacifier - Round from Gimme the Good Stuff
    Hevea Natural Round Pacifier from Gimme the Good StuffHevea Natural Round Pacifier from Gimme the Good Stuff

    Hevea Natural Rubber Pacifiers

    $9.99
    Quick View
  • Under the Nile Carrot Veggie Toy from Gimme the Good Stuff

    Under the Nile Carrot Organic Veggie Toy Teether

    $12.00
    Quick View
  • Hevea Colored Pacifier from gimme the good stuff
    Heave Natural Rubber Pacifier Baby BlushHeave Natural Rubber Pacifier Moss GreenHevea Reindeer Grey Natural Rubber Pacifier from Gimme the Good StuffHevea Natural Rubber Pacifier from Gimme the Good Stuff

    Hevea Colored Natural Rubber Pacifier

    $9.99
    Quick View
  • Under The Nile Elephant Teething Ring from Gimme the Good Stuff

    Under The Nile Elephant Organic Cotton Teether

    $17.50
    Quick View
  • Hevea Duck Teether from Gimme the Good Stuff

    Hevea Natural Rubber Duck Teether

    $17.99
    Quick View
  • Hevea Natural Rubber Pacifier Powder Pink and Milky White from Gimme the Good Stuff
    Hevea Natural Rubber Pacifier Powder Pink and Milky White from Gimme the Good StuffHevea Natural Rubber Pacifiers Hunter Green and Olive ROUND from Gimme the Good StuffHevea Natural Rubber Pacifiers Hunter Green and Olive from Gimme the Good StuffHevea Natural Rubber Pacifier Powder Pink and Milky White from Gimme the Good StuffHevea Natural Rubber Pacifier Powder Pink and Milky White from Gimme the Good Stuff

    Hevea Natural Rubber Pacifiers – 2 Pack

    $16.99
    Quick View
  • Bannor Toys Silicone and Wood Teether from Gimme the Good Stuff
    Bannor Toys Silicone and Wood Teether - Mother Nature from Gimme the Good StuffBannor Toys Riverbed Silicone and Wood Teether from Gimme the Good StuffBannor Toys Lucky Charm Silicone and Wood Teether from Gimme the Good Stuff

    Bannor Toys Silicone and Wood Teether

    $15.99
    Quick View
  • Hevea Baby Blue Natural Rubber Pacifier from Gimme the Good Stuff 002

    Hevea Baby Blue Natural Rubber Pacifier

    $9.99
    Quick View
  • Baby Bar and co Silicone Teether from Gimme the Good Stuff Baby Blue
    Three Hearts Bunny Ear Silicone Teether - Rose Dawn from Gimme the Good StuffBaby Bar and co Silicone Teether from Gimme the Good Stuff Baby's Breath

    Three Hearts Bunny Ear Silicone Teether

    $17.00
    Quick View
  • Silicone Pacifier Case from Gimme the Good Stuff Powder PinkSilicone Pacifier Case from Gimme the Good Stuff Tan BeigeSilicone Pacifier Case from Gimme the Good Stuff Sandy Nude

    Hevea Silicone Pacifier Case

    $19.99
    Quick View
  • Petit Collage Organic Cotton Book & Teether Gift Set

    Petit Collage Organic Cotton Book & Teether Gift Set

    $25.00
    Quick View