Alaffia Baby Wash & Shampoo contains safer surfactants, but their use of benzyl alcohol is disappointing. These ingredients would be fine for an adult, but when we are talking about babies I am extra uptight.
Aveeno Baby Calming Comfort Bath contains synthetic fragrance and immunotoxic cocamidopropyl betaine, plus a range of PEG chemicals.
BabyGanics Baby Shampoo & Wash is not the worst brand out there, but anything with phenoxyethanol is in the Sneaky Stuff category when it comes to products for baby.
Baby Mantra Natural Baby Wash, Shampoo & Bubble Bath has been moved from Good Stuff to Sneaky Stuff, because they’ve added benzyl alcohol.
Burt’s Bee’s Baby Shampoo & Wash is super close to being Okay Stuff, but as I keep saying, I am super extra picky with products that are used on newborns. The phenoxyethanol knocks this one down to Sneaky Stuff.
Dr. Brown’s Foaming Baby Wash claims to be a natural baby wash but definitely is not, and includes “fragrance” as an ingredient.
Everyone 3-in-1 Kids Soap I generally like this brand, and wanted to be able to call this brand Good Stuff or at least Okay Stuff. Unfortunately, the inclusion of phenoxyethanol and benzyl alcohol make this Sneaky Stuff.
Gaia Natural Baby Bath & Body Wash contains the scary formaldehyde-releasing sodium hydroxymethylglycinate. I don’t know how they get away with calling this a “natural baby wash” (other than the total lack of regulation over the term “natural.”) It also contains cocamidopropyl betaine
Gentle Naturals Eczema Baby Wash is not particularly gentle nor natural, with phenoxyethanol and several PEG chemicals among its ingredients.
Honest Baby Shampoo & Wash is almost Okay Stuff–with sodium benzoate being the only real problematic ingredient–but their scented formulas also contain limonene and linalool.
So many of you have asked about Just Hatched brand, but it’s decidedly sneaky, with fragrance, cocamidopropyl betaine, and PEG chemicals.
Little Twig Baby Wash contains suspected immunotoxin cocamidopropyl betaine and sodium benzoate.
Mustela, a high-end but Sneaky baby line, makes several formulations of baby wash that contain cocamidopropyl betaine, PEG chemicals, and synthetic fragrance.
Noodle & Boo is a Sneaky brand has phenoxyethanol, synthetic fragrance, and other questionable ingredients.
Original Sprout also contains cocamidopropyl betaine, making is Sneaky Stuff.
Puracy Natural Baby Shampoo & Body Wash has cleaned up their ingredients, so EWG’s rating is no longer accurate (they still have “fragrance” listed). It does still contain sodium benzoate, though, so it’s staying in Sneaky Stuff.
Shea Moisture Baby Wash & Shampoo contains synthetic fragrance, phenoxyethanol, sodium benzoate, and cocamidopropyl betaine–so this one is Sneaky Stuff a few times over!
Tubby Todd products used to claim they were 100% natural, which was a total lie. They’ve changed the language on the front of the bottle, but still use cocamidopropyl betaine and therefore are Sneaky Stuff.
216 comments
pncrowe31
Hi! What are your thoughts on Dove hypoallergenic wash, fragrance free, the honest products, and mustela?
pncrowe31
What are your thoughts on Dove hypoallergenic wash, fragrance free, the honest products, and mustela?
Mell
Alaffia ingredients don’t list alcohol. Maybe it changed since u wrote this?
Maia James
Looks clean to me!
Vasu Dev
These tips are full of insights and somehow these will gonna improve the babycare routine. One thing that is a must regarding baby wash that is one must have the best natural baby wash products to attain the best results. At last natural is the best a baby can have.
Thank you.
Vasu Dev
I was searching for such a piece of good advice here and there now I am satisfied with your tips, thank you so much for sharing such good knowledge and helping me with the baby body wash.
Amy Smith
Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me.
Diane
Please review Original Sprout. The label claims that it has no Parabens, pthalates or other “nastiesâ€, however it smells really good which makes me suspicious. ?? Thank you!
Nadia
Any thoughts on Alaffia kids? I find it at Thrive Market and it’s significantly cheaper than Honest Co., so I was hoping it’s a ?. Thanks!
Elis Natural
A good soap for baby is goat’s milk with honey and buttermilk
Jenny
Thoughts on the Hello Bello
Line? I love their collection and use everything from it.
Jennifer
When at the hospital they ga e me a product called Lil’O’Blossom tender newborn wash . What are your thoughts on this ? Good bad or sneaky ?
Sarah
Hello, do you have a review on dabble & dollop?
Jennifer
Sorry meant Dove
Jennifer Price
I don’t see anything on Fove baby wash or lotions . Can you give me your opinion on it ?
Mary
Really great post thank you for writing this guide on baby safety products
Lori
HI there!! Do you have any recommendations for cradle cap shampoo?
John Hamer
If you’re so against “fragrance” being listed as an ingredient then how did Tom’s of Maine make the list?
Maria
Great post. Thanks for sharing this with us.
Keep posted.
Swathi
What do you think about attitude baby leaves 2 in 1 shampoo and body wash and also honest shampoo and body wash ??
Trisha Porter
What do you think about the Puracy line at Target?
Thank you!
Nina
Hi! You have listed that the Babo bubble bath contains “natural fragrance†– do you know what this is? Bc this seems like something you would not recommend. Also reviews on amazon say the formula has changed. Do you know if this is correct? Thanks!
Caitlyn
What are your options on the wash with water line?
These are the ingredients for their 3 in 1 baby wash Aqua, Sodium Lauroyl Methyl Isethionte, Coco Betaine, Coco-Glucoside, Glycerin, Sodium Methyl Cocoyl Taurate, Organic Aloe Barbadensis (Aloe Vera) Leaf Juice, Organic Argania Spinosa (Argan) Kernel Oil, Organic Butyrospermum Parkii (Shea) Butter, Organic Cocos Nucifera (Coconut) Oil, Organic Theobroma Cacao (Cocoa) Seed Butter, Organic Molasses, Capryloyl Glycine, Organic Rosmarinus Officinalis (Rosemary) Leaf Extract, Aroma, Organic Calendula Officinalis Oil, Guar Hydroxypropyltrimonium Chloride, Potassium Sorbate, Xanthan Gum, Sodium Chloride, Citric Acid, Aroma.Alexandra
can u please test baby bum products and dove baby products? those are my top 2!
Leanne Ao-yeong
what about zoe organics?
Renee
What about Wash With Water brand?
Angela Yount
As always , love reading gimmethegoodstuff.com, the the only website I could go and trust, thank you for your great info!
I’m currently looking for wash since I need to buy more and also have baby coming in the next few weeks. I was looking into these two as well as MADE OF , what are your thoughts on those. thanks! Attitude 2-in-1 Natural Hair and Body Foaming Wash Baby, Fragrance Free Babo Botanicals Sensitive Baby Fragrance Free Shampoo and Wash (and they have the foaming option too)Kelsey Sullivan
Maia,
Do you have a recommendation for baby eczema wash?Micki
My son had a reaction to the Weleda. I didn’t even bother to read the ingredients and then I saw that it is made with almond oil and sesame oil, both of which my son is allergic to. Besides that though, it has carrageenan as a top 10 ingredient, which i know is linked to cancer. I can’t believe that they would put that in a baby product!
Priyanka Bansal
Hi, I skimmed through the blog and found that some baby care companies use toxins and chemicals, but there are Babo Botanicals, Bella b which makes 100% natural and organic products. A lot of products are even EWG and Made Safe certified which ensures they are safe to use for kids and even their mama.
Erinn
You haven’t actually addressed Tubby Todd’s ingredients. You’ve said they’re full of it with their 100% natural claims. That’s cool but is it actually safe to use on our babies? Is the synthetic ingredients they have at least okay to use? They seem pretty great to me. Would like to have a more in depth opinion from you. Thanks!
Kelly
Hello! Thanks to you I found a love the Babo line. I ordered quite a bit a while back and honestly didn’t even look at the ingredients because I thought the whole line was “good stuff.” Then after reading on your guide that they added sodium benzoate I checked our Babo products to see if they contained it. They did not, but two products contained “natural fragrance.” What is your thought on this? I know I read once on your site only to trust fragrance that says it 100% essential oils. Thanks!
Julia Luna
Hi! Thank you so much for your guises, it has made life much easier in finding safe products for my family.
What are your thoughts on the brand “Wash with Waterâ€. They have a whole line of baby and kid products.Sarah
I am constantly eager to find out about new… I am taking in your blog… your blog is too great… however incorporate more points,your web journals is looking much good… for more points best soaps for baby please visit link I given below
Shannon
Curious if you have reviewed California baby’s lotion and baby washes in the sensitive skin line (I see that you have the bubble bath). Appreciate all the work you do!
Paula
Hi! Would love to hear your thoughts on the Puracy products.
Thanks for the comprehensive posting!
Evonne
Sorry I meant Babo Botanicals, Sensitive Baby, Daily Hydra Lotion, Fragrance Free and not the Babo Botanicals, Sensitive Skin, Hydra Therapy Lotion, Fragrance Free for adults.
Evonne
One of your top picks is the Babo Botanicals, 3 in 1: Shampoo, Bubble Bath & Wash, Lavender Meadowsweet. What about the Babo Botanicals, Sensitive Baby, Shampoo & Wash, Fragrance Free? Im deciding between the two.
Also what are your thoughts on Babo Botanicals, Sensitive Skin, Hydra Therapy Lotion, Fragrance Free?
Grandma Suggs
Maia -
Thanks for maintaining such a useful site! I recently read about potential endocrine disruption effects of essential oils, including lavender. I haven’t looked too deeply into this yet (not sure of concentration needed to cause alarm), but I thought I’d call this to your attention: https://www.google.com/search?q=lavender oil&source=lnms&tbm=nws&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi0lP2b0avaAhURMd8KHfaHCncQ_AUIDCgD&biw=1388&bih=908 Any thoughts on this? Does this change your opinion of the Babo Botanical and Baby Mantra products, both of which contain lavender?Jackie
Hello,
You say stay away from fragrance but one of the stuff you recommend and you use on your kids is the Babo bubble bath Lavender, where does the lavender come from?
thanks
Missy
What do you think of Babyganics?
Ashley
Never mind! I see that you already responded to that :)
Ashley
I thought Carrageenan was a bad ingredient but it is listed in the Babo bubble bath…?
Maia James
Yes! Totally safe!
Maia James
It doesn’t mean anything in terms of safety, but I’ll look into this brand!
NK
What are your thoughts on the Alaffia products? Also, Interested in your thoughts on ‘fair trade’ and how it relates to product safety. Thank you
mprichgels
What are your thoughts about Little Seed Farm? They make organic bar soaps and baby balm and all other stuff for face.
NK
Thank you for the updated list. What are your thoughts on the Alaffia products- body washes and lotions? Not sure how ‘fair trade’ translates to safety.
Melissa Richgels
Hello,
I saw Babyganics bubble bath in sneaky stuff but what about the Babyganics Foaming Shampoo and Body Wash Fragrance Free? Thank you!Melissa Richgels
Hello Maia,
What do you think about Mamasuds body wash (for babies and adults). Ingredient is diluted saponified olive oil.
Thank you.