Healthy(ish) Homemade Ice Cream Cake

Written by:

Maia James


Some of you asked for the recipe for our homemade ice cream cake that I mentioned in the newsletter. Here are the details!

For my son’s seventh birthday, he requested an ice cream cake with candy on top. We live near a candy shop, and we let him choose the aquatic-themed gummies that went on top of the cake (nothing about this candy was remotely Good Stuff, besides the joy it brought him and his brother).

The cake itself wasn’t actually that bad, especially when you consider what’s in a Carvel ice cream cake! We followed this recipe, with the following alternations:

  1. We used Blue Marble ice cream (which is organic…and $8 a pint!). You could also choose Alden’s Organic ice cream, or better yet, make your own ice cream and completely skip the white sugar. Here’s a truly easy recipe for making ice cream.
  2. For the cake’s middle cookie crumble layer, we got natural chocolate wafer cookies (like these), and used this recipe to make our own chocolate shell. (The cake recipe calls for Magic Shell, which surprisingly didn’t include anything THAT terrible, other than lots of sugar and some soy lecithin. Still, I wanted to make an organic version with higher quality coconut oil.)
  3. As for the icing, it was just whipped cream with a little maple syrup. Felix wanted it to look like the ocean (since the candy he chose was under-water themed), and my husband was worried that we wouldn’t be able to get natural food coloring that would be the right color. I proved him wrong, though, and a mere $20 later, I had some natural food coloring that really worked!

If you’re keeping track, you’ve probably realized that this cake cost nearly $100 to make! If you’ve attempted a homemade ice cream cake, comment below on lessons learned and what you spent:).

Stay sane,

Maia, Founder & CEO

Note: This article contains affiliate links or sponsored content, which means that if you make a purchase, we may earn a commission. We only recommend products that meet our strict standards for non-toxicity and that we use (or want to use!) ourselves. Thank you so much for supporting the brands that make Good Stuff! 

Enjoying this guide?

Join the 60,000 families who rely on our free non toxic product reviews to buy everything from milk to mattresses!

Related Posts


Healthy Thanksgiving Recipes

Posted on
Here are our favorite healthy Thanksgiving recipes, plus other ways to make this holiday saner!

Daylon’s Healthier Fried Chicken Sandwich

Posted on
My kids love a Chic-fil-A fried chicken sandwich, but for obvious reasons, I am not a fan. Recently, my husband cracked the code! What follows is his recipe for a…

Healthy Yogurt Guide

Posted on
For this version of the yogurt guide, we reviewed our 26 brands to find the healthiest yogurt.

Healthiest Popsicles Guide

Posted on
Making your own will result in the very healthiest fruit popsicles, especially since every store-bought one comes in plastic. Sometimes it makes sense to buy fruit pops to have on…

2023 Fresh & Frozen Baby Food Guide

Posted on
1. Little Spoon / 2. Yumi / 3. Bambino’s / 4. Tiny Organics / 5. Lil Gourmets / 6. Once Upon a Farm The best baby food is homemade. But fresh or frozen baby food you buy is the next…

Store-Bought Cookie Guide: the Healthiest Cookies We Found

Posted on
1. Hu / 2. Butterfly Bakery / 3. Maxine’s Heavenly / 4. Cappello’s / 5. Siete / 6. Simple Mills I still believe that the healthiest cookies are the ones you make at home. You can bake cookies with the highest-quality, natural, organic…

Leave a Reply