Never List

OUR STANDARDS

The Gimme the Good Stuff 'Never List'

Ingredients & materials we avoid and why context matters

At Gimme the Good Stuff, we don't evaluate products based on fear-driven marketing claims or ingredient lists stripped of context. Instead, our standards take into account the broader picture, including:

Scientific Evidence

The quality of the scientific evidence behind an ingredient.

Exposure Route & Concentration

How and how much we’re exposed to makes a big difference.

Frequency of Use

How often the ingredient is used in real life matters.

Vulnerable Populations

We prioritize infants, children, and other sensitive groups.

Environmental Impact

We consider persistence and ecosystem effects.

Some ingredients are categorically unacceptable. Others depend heavily on how they're used, in what amounts, and by whom. This list outlines the ingredients and practices we avoid most carefully, along with the contexts in which exposure meaningfully changes the level of concern. This list is updated as new research emerges and formulations change.

'Natural' Does Not Always Mean Safer

One of the most common misconceptions in the wellness industry is that 'natural' automatically means safer or healthier than synthetic alternatives. That is not how toxicology works. For example:

  • Natural vitamin C from fruit extracts is chemically identical to synthetic ascorbic acid.
  • Some synthetic ingredients are actually more stable, purified, and predictable than their naturally derived counterparts.
  • Indeed, many naturally derived compounds, including essential oils and heavy metals, can still pose meaningful risks depending on exposure and concentration.

How to read this table

We evaluate each ingredient using a contextual, science-informed approach.

KEY CONSIDERATIONS

Evidence First

We start with the best available scientific research.

Context is Critical

Safety depends on exposure route, concentration, and user profile.

Balance & Transparency

We weigh risks and benefits and value full ingredient disclosure.

Living Standards

Our standards evolve with new science and real-world data.

LEGEND (USED IN THE TABLE)

HT
Human Toxicants

Potential harm to human health

ED
Exposure Dependent

Risk depends on how it’s used

EC
Environmental Concerns

Potential harm to ecosystems

T&D
Transparency & Disclosure

Issues with labeling or disclosure

INGREDIENT ⇅ CLASSIFICATION ⇅ COMMON USES WHY CONTEXT MATTERS / WHY WE AVOID IT ⇅ TAGS
1,4-Dioxane (Ethoxylation Byproduct) Requires full disclosure/testing Potential contaminant in ethoxylated ingredients like SLES or PEGs

Probable carcinogenic contaminant. The concern is contamination level, not necessarily the base ingredient itself. Brands should verify purification and residual testing.

HT T&D
Aluminum Starch Octenylsuccinate Never for infants/children; Never in aerosolized or inhalable products for adults Powders, cosmetics, sunscreens, first-aid products

Potential respiratory irritation. Concern is primarily related to inhalation exposure and especially vulnerable populations, especially infants.

HT ED
Antimony Never in infant/child products. Adults– full disclosure and testing. Polyester textiles, plastics, synthetic fabrics

Potential carcinogen; heavy metal contaminant; respiratory toxicant. Antimony may remain as a manufacturing residue in certain materials. Concern depends on concentration, migration potential, and duration of exposure.

HT T&D ED
Artificial Colors & Flavors in Children’s Products Never in infant/child ingestibles; avoid when possible for adults Gummies, snacks, wellness supplements

These additives offer little functional benefit and may contribute to behavioral concerns in sensitive children.

HT T&D
Bamboo Viscose (“Eco-Friendly” Rayon) Use with awareness Textiles, wipes, diapers

Environmental pollution concerns. Bamboo itself is renewable, but converting it into viscose rayon requires chemical-intensive processing. “Plant-based” does not automatically equal environmentally benign.

EC
Benzalkonium Chloride (BAK) & Quaternary Ammonium Compounds (“Quats”) Never for products intended for routine inhalation exposure around children Disinfectants, sanitizers, cleaning sprays, wipes

Concerns include respiratory irritation, sensitization, and repeated inhalation
exposure, especially in children and sensitive individuals; concerning also for aquatic/ecosystem toxicity.

HT EC ED
Bisphenols (BPA, BPS, BPF) Never in food-contact products Plastic containers, can linings, receipts

Bisphenols are endocrine-active chemicals that can migrate into food and beverages.

HT
Carrageenan (Certain Processed Forms) Never in infant formula (can be safe in other products with full disclosure/transparency) Dairy alternatives, processed foods

Safety concerns depend on the form, processing conditions, and level of exposure. While food-grade carrageenan differs from degraded carrageenan (poligeenan), some researchers have raised concerns about gastrointestinal inflammation, particularly in infants and other vulnerable populations.

ED
Coal Tar & Coal-Tar Dyes Never Hair dyes, specialty skincare products

Coal tar contains compounds associated with carcinogenicity and offers limited
justification in modern consumer products.

HT
Essential Oils (and Terpenes) Never for infants/newborns; adults use with caution Fragrance, skincare, aromatherapy

Skin sensitizers; respiratory irritants. Essential oils are highly concentrated bioactive compounds. Exposure that may be low-risk for healthy adults can be inappropriate for infants or sensitive individuals.

HT EC
Formaldehyde-Releasing Preservatives Never Shampoo, lotion, cosmetics

These preservatives slowly release formaldehyde over time and may contribute to sensitization and long-term toxicity concerns.

HT EC
Heavy Metals (Lead, Arsenic, Cadmium, Mercury) Never above trace regulatory thresholds (naturally occurring and unavoidable in trace amounts, in certain products) Contamination in foods, supplements, pigments, cosmetics

Neurotoxicity; developmental toxicity; bioaccumulation. Heavy metals accumulate in the body and are especially concerning for infants and children.

HT T&D
Microplastics (Polyethylene, Polypropylene Beads, etc.) Never in children’s products; avoid when possible for adults Exfoliants, cosmetics, toothpaste

Ecosystem contamination; bioaccumulation concerns. Persistent environmental pollutants with growing concern around ingestion and ecosystem contamination.

HT EC
Nanoparticles / Nanomaterials (e.g., nanosilver, nano zinc, nano titanium dioxide) Requires full disclosure/testing; never in infant ingestibles or inhalable products without safety data Sunscreens, sprays, supplements, antimicrobial products

Respiratory inflammation; uncertain bioaccumulation concerns. Safety depends heavily on particle size, exposure route, and the potential for inhalation or systemic absorption.

HT T&D
Optical Brighteners Never for baby textiles; adults use with caution Laundry detergents and fabric treatments

These compounds remain on fabric surfaces and may contribute to skin irritation and environmental persistence.

EC
Oxybenzone & Octinoxate Never Chemical UV filters in sunscreen

Concerns include systemic absorption and endocrine activity, particularly in vulnerable populations.

HT T&D EC
PEG Compounds (Polyethylene Glycols) Requires full disclosure/testing; avoid where possible Emulsifiers, creams, lotions

Carcinogenic contamination concern; petrochemical processing concern. Petroleum-derived, PEGs themselves are not necessarily highly toxic, but poorly purified PEGs may contain residual contaminants such as ethylene oxide or 1,4-dioxane.

T&D EC
PFAS (“Forever Chemicals”) Never Non-stick cookware, stain-resistant fabrics, waterproof coatings

PFAS chemicals are highly persistent, bioaccumulative, and associated with
immune, hormonal, developmental, and environmental concerns. They do not break down meaningfully in the environment.

HT EC
PVC / Vinyl Never in baby products Mattress covers, bibs, toys

Phthalate exposure concern; environmentally persistent chlorine-based plastics. Often associated with phthalates and chlorine-intensive manufacturing.

T&D EC
Parabens (e.g., methylparaben, propylparaben, butylparaben) Never Lotions, shampoos, cosmetics, personal care products

Parabens are preservatives associated with endocrine disruption. Concern depends on exposure level, frequency of use, and whether the product is leave-on or rinse-off however, we recommend avoiding parabens in all products.

HT ED
Phthalates (DEP, DBP, DEHP, etc.) Never Fragrance, plastics, vinyl materials

Certain phthalates are linked to endocrine disruption and reproductive toxicity,
particularly during early development.

HT T&D
Proprietary Blends in Children’s Supplements Requires full disclosure/testing Wellness powders, gummies, supplements

Transparency/disclosure concern. Lack of transparency prevents meaningful safety evaluation.

T&D
SLS / SLES (Sodium Lauryl Sulfate / Sodium Laureth Sulfate) Never for infant skin products; avoid when alternatives exist in adult rinse-off products Shampoo, cleansers, dish soap

Skin and eye irritants; contamination concern (1,4-dioxane). These surfactants can be irritating at higher concentrations or with prolonged exposure, but risk is substantially lower in diluted rinse-off products.

HT EC ED
Talc Never for infant powders or inhalation-prone products Baby powder, cosmetics, body powders

The primary concerns are asbestos contamination and inhalation exposure,
particularly in infants and children.

HT T&D
Titanium Dioxide & Nanoparticles (Inhalation Contexts) Never in inhalable powders or sprays without safety verification Powder makeup, spray sunscreens

Possible carcinogenicity when aerosolized. Risk depends heavily on particle size and inhalation exposure.

HT ED
Toluene & Aromatic Solvents Never, especially in products intended for children or during pregnancy Nail polish, adhesives, solvent-based cosmetics

These solvents are associated with neurotoxicity and inhalation concerns, particularly with repeated exposure.

HT
Undisclosed Essential Oil Blends Never for infant products “Natural” skincare and baby care

Sensitization and irritation; transparency concern. Essential oils are often marketed as inherently safe because they are plant-derived, but many are potent sensitizers or respiratory irritants.

T&D
Undisclosed “Fragrance” / Parfum Never Personal care and cleaning products

Allergen/sensitization concern; hidden phthalate exposure. “Fragrance” can legally conceal dozens or hundreds of undisclosed chemicals, including allergens and phthalates.

HT T&D EC

For Readers

Subscribe to our newsletter to receive updated guides and new product evaluations.

Subscribe to Newsletter

For Brands

Submit products for review through the Brand Portal.

Access Brand Portal