The Honest Company by Jessica Alba: Good, Bad, or Sneaky?

Written by:

Maia James


Updated: 09/29/2023

Looking for a different guide? Browse them all HERE.

We get multiple emails a day asking about Jessica Alba’s line of baby and household products, The Honest Company, whose mission is “to reduce the ubiquitous presence of toxic chemicals in our our natural environment, man-made environments, and our personal environments.”

It seems that Gimme the Good Stuff readers are all dying to know: Is The Honest Company truly good stuff?

I’d feel comfortable using most of the products in the Honest line (and give my private clients the green light on the diapers, which people seem to particularly love), but unfortunately there are a couple that are Sneaky: namely, the hand wash and the dish soap. Honest Auto Dishwasher Gel and Honest Laundry Detergent are questionable as they have undisclosed ingredients (see below).

I think Jessica Alba was coming from a sincere place when she created this company, and the website is more or less transparent, with a few vexing exceptions (see below).

Some people might not like the following:

  • The diapers contain SAP (less than conventional brands, however).
  • Some Honest products contain the preservative sodium benzoate.
  • Honest products are not 100% natural–they all contain a variety of synthetics, although for the most part these are synthetics that seem to be safe.
  • Some ingredients don’t have any safety data available (sodium lauroyl oat amino acid, for instance).
  • SNEAKY: Honest Hand Wash contains phenoxyethanol. This isn’t the very worst ingredient, but not the Good Stuff. Honest Dish Soap contains cocamidopropyl betaine, phenoxyethanol, and methylisothiazolinone.
  • MAYBE SNEAKY: Honest Laundry Detergent contains “100% biodegradable anionic coconut kernel-oil based surfactant” and the Honest Auto Dishwasher Gel contains “biodegradable low foam surfactant.” No one at the company can tell us any more detail about what these ingredients are, other than that they are “corn-based.” We’ve called several times.

Bottom Line: This stuff is much better than anything conventional you will buy, and stacks up well against most natural brands. Avoid the dish soap and hand wash.

Oh, and here are our picks for:

Stay sane,

Maia, Founder & CEO

Note: This article contains affiliate links or sponsored content, which means that if you make a purchase, we may earn a commission. We only recommend products that meet our strict standards for non-toxicity and that we use (or want to use!) ourselves. Thank you so much for supporting the brands that make Good Stuff! 

Enjoying this guide?

Join 60K families who rely on our free guides on everything from milk to mattresses! Sign up to get $5 off your first order, access to our ultimate Clean Products Cheat Sheet, and ongoing exclusive access to coupon codes and promotions. Our weekly newsletter is filled with well researched tips and tricks to live a toxin-free lifestyle.
Image showing various bar soaps. | Gimme The Good Stuff

The Best Natural Soap Guide 2024

Posted on
When it comes bar soap, the good news is that there are tons of safe options for organic soap. The bad news is that many of these soaps are difficult…

The Best Non Toxic Baby Bottles

Posted on
Even as a breastfeeding mom, I wanted to find the best non toxic baby bottles to have on hand. (The hope was that my babies would accept nighttime bottles of…

Non-Toxic Air Freshener Guide

Posted on
Most traditional air fresheners contain chemicals that aren’t labeled. Here’s our guide to non-toxic, natural air fresheners.

Leave a Reply

  1. Ike Avatar

    If you have severe soap allergies and reactions, I would recommend Nutriobiotics Coconut Oil Liquid Soaps. I couldn’t use Honest soaps.

    1. Mary Lynn DeVito Avatar
      Mary Lynn DeVito

      My daughter is allergic to coconut. With it appearing in so many products as a ‘safe’ ingredient it is a struggle to find a safe cleanser that she does not react to.

  2. Deb Avatar

    Will you do an updated version of this? I’m trying to do better about less toxic stuff for my family. And came across this but was hoping to find an updated one.

  3. Johanne Avatar

    Hi, is there any animal testing done on her products ? Thanks !

  4. Morgan Souza Avatar
    Morgan Souza

    Maia, would you consider doing an update on Honest now that they have rolled out a whole new line of cleaning, laundry, and other household products? Thanks!

  5. JDP Avatar

    Any updates on this? They are back in the news again with a class action lawsuit…I can’t find a list of the actual ingredients that are considered toxic and what products they are in and it is driving me a bit nuts and leading me into endless web searching! I currently use the diapers, the organic healing balm (as diaper cream), the sweet orange vanilla shampoo and body wash (for my toddler), and just picked up the face and body lotion (for my soon to be newborn). Then I hear about all the bad stuff in regards to the class action suit. I can find the list of the products, but not the actual ingredients they are saying are “toxic”. To me saying they are making “natural” products but actually using synthetic ingredients is just morally wrong, but ultimately not that concerning if the synthetic ingredients are not actually toxic. But there are claims they are using proven toxic ingredients – which I would like to know what those ingredients are to check the products of theirs I use. That would be a deal breaker for me and I would no longer use the products that had ingredients in it that could affect my baby’s health! Thanks for all your work you do here guys!

  6. Corin Avatar

    I have had a bundle subscription with Honest for about a year now, and really love most of the products. I have noticed they seem to be discontinuing several items, and when I customized my most recent bundle they are out of stock on a bunch more items. I am concerned that there are problems with the company itself. Have you heard anything?

  7. Maria Avatar

    Hi! Do you have any updated news on the Honest Co. products? I’m thinking of ordering the hand/body lotion, feminine pads, deodorant, hand soap, bug spray and laundry detergent.


    1. Maia James Avatar
      Maia James

      I haven’t done an updated review yet, but it’s on my list! I appreciate your patience.

  8. Arlene Avatar

    Hello there,
    I was thinking in buying the face and body lotion, but after I read your article, im not so sure. Do you recommended? Im looking for a good body lotion, i was using the ones by ‘kiss my face’ but Recently i started to inform myself about the ingredients of the products i use, and im trying to change as many of them as I can. Please advise. Thank you 🙂

    1. Maia James Avatar
      Maia James

      Honest lotion doesn’t have anything especially alarming in it, but I do understand why some people have lost trust in this company. For a basic, low cost lotion, I would recommend one of the Acure lotions:

  9. megan Avatar

    Unfortunately it appears the honest co. is not so honest with a very important product – infant formula!
    “The lawsuit against The Honest Co. alleges that the company is falsely representing its Premium Infant Formula as “organic,” when the product in fact contains 11 substances prohibited by federal law from organics. Some of the ingredients are federally regulated as hazardous compounds. At least one is irradiated. And some have not even been assessed as safe for human foods, much less for infant formulas.”
    Full article here:

  10. Kate Avatar

    Hi! The face and body lotion- is that safe and safe while pregnant ?

    1. Maia James Avatar
      Maia James

      Yes, I would personally feel comfortable using it.

  11. Ollie Avatar

    We really like the Honest healing balm. We use it as a diaper rash cream and it works wonderfully. All good ingredients.

  12. Heidi Avatar

    I Was Wondering If They Changed There Hand Soap As Well As They Did There Dish Soap Or Is It Still Sneaky?

    1. Maia James Avatar
      Maia James

      Hi Heidi!
      I need to revisit the whole line of Honest products, and will be providing an updated review in the coming months!

      1. Heidi Avatar

        Ok Thank You So Much.. I Was Just Asking Because I Had Ordered A Trial Package And In That Package It Comes With The Hand Soap And Body Wash So I Was Just Wondering If They Changed That As Well As The Dish Soap..

  13. Tabatha Avatar

    I was wondering if there is anyway to find out if the use soybean oil in their body oil or anything else. I know it’s not required to be list as an ingredient in some things because it’s not considered an allergen. I tried contacting them and just got told the ingredients are listed on the site.

    1. Maia James Avatar
      Maia James

      Hi there-
      Beyond asking the company for a complete list of ingredients or sending a sample to a lab for testing, I don’t know another way to confirm the presence of a trace of soy.

  14. Tiffany Avatar

    What do you think about the toothpaste ingredients from the honest company. I’ve been seeing a post going around on Facebook about if your toothpaste has a certain color stripe on the crease it indicates whether it’s full of chemicals ie: if there’s a black strip there’s a lot if chemicals or if it’s green it natural, blue is supposed to be natural + medicine. Well there’s a black strip on the honest company toothpaste so brings me to wonder what is actually true

    1. Maia James Avatar
      Maia James

      Hi Tiffany-
      No, this is not true. The colors on the bottom of the tube have nothing to do with the ingredients.

  15. mersunflower Avatar

    After the whole thing with their sunscreen (it was found out they didn’t add enough zinc to work and it intensified the sunburn) I don’t trust them. Their diapers worked for my son until he was 4 months then suddenly he was leaking out of them and they were awful. I don’t trust them anymore.

  16. Carah Counts Avatar
    Carah Counts

    I have been a customer of Honest for a while… I have been honestly (no pun intended) wondering the validity of the “organicness” of the product, and, in an effort to validate my investment, began doing some research. Landed on your site — thank you for your candid reviews. Makes it really helpful as a consumer!

    I just ordered new Honest dish soap and the bottle said it had a new and improved formula… I am wondering (hoping) some of your no-no items were removed!

    1. Maia James Avatar
      Maia James

      Yes, they removed a lot of the Bad Stuff! At this point the only ingredient I don’t love is the sodium benzoate–otherwise the dish soap is a pretty good option:).

  17. NG Avatar

    Where can I see the full list of ingredients for the Sonett Liquid Laundry detergent? Their website is pretty vague with things like ‘sugar surfactant’. I am wary because I have seen sodium cocs-sulfate as surfactant derived from coconut etc: But on reading up many people advise against sodium coco-sulfate.


    1. Maia James Avatar
      Maia James

      Hi there-
      I just emailed you a massive document from Sonett with all their ingredients in all their products! T

  18. Brandy Fisk Avatar
    Brandy Fisk

    I usually use vinegar and water to clean but, I would love to find a laundry soap and bath products that are safe. Are there other safer products a the same price point as Honest co?

    1. Maia James Avatar
      Maia James

      If you sign up for our newsletter (upper left corner of the homepage), you can download our Safe Cleaning Products Guide, which lists a bunch of safe brands of different price points.

  19. NonToxicMama Avatar


    What are your thoughts on the Honest Baby Wash & Shampoo? Any no-no’s in there?

    1. Maia James Avatar
      Maia James

      no, not really. i consider this product safe. thanks for writing!

  20. john Avatar

    Yes, the Honest Company All-Purpose cleaner is definitely safer than other conventional brands like Lysol. Still, an even better all-purpose is this:

  21. Sundie Avatar

    I was wondering if you can share your thoughts on the honest company “all purpose cleaner” is that pretty safe to use compare to other brands that contains bleach Lysol cleaners and other countertop cleaners?? I use dr. bronner’s soap for hand wash and sometime dish washing. However I’ve been searching for all purpose house cleaning supply that is not so toxic and does the job well done. Thank you so much

  22. Maia Avatar

    Hi Alissa-
    The laundry packs by Honest get our okay. There are cleaner detergents out there, but if you like the Honest pods, I think they are fine.

  23. Alissa Arndt Avatar
    Alissa Arndt

    I was wondering about the 4-in-1 laundry pods?

  24. Maia Avatar

    Hi Katie-
    I got my information from the website and a couple of phone calls to the company; I've not yet held a bottle of the soap in my hand, and I'm disappointed to hear that the ingredients listed there are vague and, frankly, sneaky. I agree that there is an inconsistency between the ostensible mission of the company and not only the inclusion of such chemicals, but also the intentional obscuring of their inclusion! That said, I have to reiterate what I said in my post: I think Jessica Alba is sincerely passionate about making safe products, and the vast majority of the Honest line is clean, safe, and…well, honest. It's unfortunate that the dish soap is such a glaring exception.

    1. amy Avatar

      But is the dish soap and laundry detergent still safer than other traditional brands?

      1. Maia James Avatar
        Maia James

        Yes, Amy, still better than Dawn etc.

  25. katie Avatar

    Where does it say that the dish soap contains the ingredients: cocamidopropyl betaine, phenoxyethanol, and methylisothiazolinone. On the bottle it says water and coconut oil derived surfactants. Are all those things what makes coconut oil derived surcactants?

    Update before I even send. I just need to say, I am surprised that the label of a company who's goal is to be completely transparent, was not so transparent. I went to the website and now the dish soap has an 'updated scent' of white grapefruit and spells out those ingredients you mentioned instead of what's on my bottle, "Water, and coconut oil derived surfactants.". I am disappointed in the 'honest' company and will not be purchasing from them again.