By John, Certified Holistic Health Coach
This might be hard to believe, but there is an upside to the Tide Pod Challenge phenomenon that you’ve probably seen in the news lately. It has caused scientists, doctors, politicians, newscasters and even Tide itself to publicly announce what our readers have known for a long time, which is that these laundry products contain “highly concentrated, toxic detergent.”
That’s right, “TOXIC.” Those are also the words of the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. Tide laundry detergent is toxic.
Obviously, nobody should eat any laundry product (even the ones
we call Good Stuff!), but we’ve known for years that most major brands contain a wide array of toxic ingredients.
Chief among these concerns is a chemical known as 1,4-dioxane. According to the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, exposure to this compound can cause eye and nose irritation, kidney problems, and possible long-term lung damage.
The EPA on 1,4-Dioxane
“1,4-Dioxane is used as a solvent. Acute (short-term) inhalation exposure to high levels of 1,4-dioxane has caused vertigo, drowsiness, headache, anorexia, and irritation of the eyes, nose, throat, and lungs in humans…Damage to the liver and kidneys has been observed in rats chronically (long-term) exposed in their drinking water… Tumors have been observed in orally exposed animals. EPA has classified 1,4-dioxane as a Group B2, probable human carcinogen.”
1,4-dioxane is commonly found in Tide and many other major brands of laundry detergent, whether or not you see it listed as an ingredient.
Phthalates in Laundry Detergent
Another toxin is something as benign sounding as “fragrance.” Fragrance, as you’ve probably heard us mention, is almost always packed with a group of chemicals known as phthalates, which cannegatively affect reproductive systems, endocrine systems, and infant development.
Don’t Detergent Toxins Wash Out?
So my question is; why would we wash our clothes with known toxins?
It would be easy to think that these toxins simply wash down the drain (and into lakes, rivers, and oceans), and yes they do wind up in the environment and cause all sorts of problems there.
In addition, ingredients in these toxic laundry products are intentionally made to stick to fabrics, mostly to keep our clothes smelling “clean.” This means that as we wear our clothes and sweat, these chemicals break down and are being absorbed through our skin. So when we use these products we are being exposed to these chemicals essentially all the time, even when we sleep.
Alternatives to Tide’s Toxic Laundry Detergent
The fact is that there is very little meaningful regulation around cleaning and laundry products, so it’s up to each of us to stay informed.
Gimme the Good Stuff is far from the first to bring awareness to these problems, but we do offer alternatives to toxic laundry detergents. Below are some of our very favorite safe laundry soaps and detergents. (But still, don’t eat them!).
Stay sane,
Check Out Our Safe Laundry Guide
Tallow-based laundry soap works as well as detergent and may not trigger eczema.
Tandi’s Naturals Concentrated Laundry Soap
From: $16.49 / monthBuy Now
Christina Maser Concentrated Laundry Soap
$22.00 – $29.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Buy Now
$18.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Buy Now
$29.99 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Buy Now
Pure Natural Laundry Detergent
From: $24.99 / monthBuy Now
If you liked this post, sign up for our newsletter to be alerted when we publish new content like this!
Pamela says
The only reason I was considering Tide is because my sister uses it and her clothes always smell so good. (I usually get the dollar store stuff) Do these leave your clothes smelling good, or just not dirty?
Suzanne Weaver-Goss says
Hi Pamela, Yes Tide and many detergents do make the clothing smell. This is a personal preference and I am the opposite of you; I do not like the perfume smell on clothing and maybe that’s because I know how unhealthy it is! Especially for children and clothing that has that “smell” has to be washed numerous times to get the smell out. It’s not worth sacrificing your health for the smell. There are some products that are scented with essential oils like lavender, however those scents aren’t as strong as synthetic fragrance. I would recommend Sonett Lavender Laundry or Tandi’s Natural Lavender or Citrusy Trio. Both natural, smell good and healthy! https://bit.ly/3uRLltZ
https://bit.ly/3hsGwnc
ricky ly says
Yes. We used 10ml of our plant based biodegradable liquid detergent Per Load . It’s safe, effective, concentrated & affordable ($0.187/load). 100% safety guaranteed & Made in USA. Can contact me for more info. rickyly143@gmail.com.
Jamie says
Has anybody tried Tru Earth products? It keeps popping up on Instagram and I’ve been wanting to find a good alternative…
Jeannine says
I use Biokleen. It costs between $20-$26 on amazon and you get 300 loads out of it! You end up using much less because of the concentration.
katmeow says
I also use Biokleen and they have one type called “sport” that gets the smelliest sweaty clothes clean!
Marianne Guinee says
Melaleuca’s Melapower is the best detergent out there. Affordable and safe, both for humans and the environment.
Dave says
Is All Free and Clear safe?
Abbey says
I have been using some plant based detergents for a while now and have been trying to convert my husband too. His big issue (and I don’t disagree) are that our workout clothes don’t get clean. Do you have a recommendation for an eco-friendly laundry soap that has the power to clean really sweaty clothes?
Suzanne Weaver-Goss says
Hi Abbey, My husband and I have work-out clothes and of course they get clean. However, I switch back and forth between plant based and the old fashioned soap that we sell made from tallow. I’ve never noticed that the plant based don’t clean as well but you might give that a try unless you are committed to only use plant based soap. You don’t mention a brand, have you tried our plant-based brands?
Amy Vallejo says
I highly highly recommend Norwex they have a sportzyme which is enzyme based and there laundry detergent just amazes me and can be used as an all purpose spray too!
You only need a teaspoon in your HE front loading machine, yes a teaspoon! Look me up
https://amyvallejo.norwex.biz/
Moriah Hanisburgh says
Was looking for an affordable alternative a while back after I first read this article. There were a few “pure” products I found and tried from my local Walmart, but for whatever reason, they left a weird (not nasty, but just weird) smell and texture to the clothes after wash.
Few more days of searching and I came across this product: http://bit.ly/NoMoreDetergent , which doesn’t even use detergent at all!
Of course I was skeptical at first, but after washing 2 large loads I can say it does indeed wash clean. No different than when I used detergents and detergent boosters.
Hope that helps others like myself.
Moirah
Kelly says
Thanks for shedding light on this. I was working on a post last week highlighting the dangers of Tide and offering alternative options, so this is perfect timing! I’ll cite some of this in an upcoming article. It’s a shame Tide has hid this from the public. I can’t believe they don’t even disclose their ingredients on the packaging (too many ingredients and toxicity to count!).
In response to John above – luckily, there are affordable alternatives (such as Grab Green, Eco-Me, greenshield Organic) on Amazon, Target, and Walmart as inexpensive as $10. These alternatives use less of a serving size than Tide and other toxic detergents too, so you’re using less but getting more out of washes. I hope that helps!
John says
Most, if not the majority of families cannot afford 27 dollar laundry detergent. If we want this toxic laundry issue to be remedied and taken seriously, we have to give families affordable non toxic options. Toxic products are affordable and have generational sentimentality attached to them. People do not like change. Facilitating change means offering affordable and easily attainable sources. Thank you.
Julie says
If you click on the product link you see it’s TWO bottles for this price. That makes it on par with other natural detergents I’ve used (maybe just a few dollars higher).
PJ says
Yes, I agree. The companies that sell these “safe” products are no better than the companies that sell the “toxic” products. Only those fortunate enough to be able to afford these safe products can protect their families?? Some of us hard working middle class people struggle just to make ends meet. When they start selling their product for $20 for a bottle that will clean 100 loads of laundry, then they can brag about what a great company they are and how much they care about making a better world for all of us!
STaylor71 says
They do sell products for under $20. Try MelaPower, it cleans amazing. Most my family is allergic to most detergents and no one has had issues with the laundry soap. It is under $20 for 97 loads.
Liliana says
My problem so far has been that I have not found a soap that actually cleans. As you make rankings and suggestions, can you also talk about effectiveness of the soaps?
thanks!
Connie J. Burgan says
If you haven’t tried PURE detergent, you are missing something great! There are no chemicals left on the fabric, your clothes are clean and you don’t need a dryer sheet. Doesn’t get much better than that – oh, unless you have a stain. THEN you realize the good stuff. Pour it on the stain full strength, leave overnight, wash as usual. BOOM! The stain is gone. If the article of clothing has been washed and dried many, many times – no problem. This stuff is magic!!