Honest Review of Beautycounter Anti-Aging Products

Written by:

Maia James


Updated: 01/23/2024

Looking for a different guide? Browse them all HERE.

Above is a photo of my nightstand, and on it you’ll see the three Beautycounter anti-aging products I’m currently putting on my skin before bed. A lot of you have written in raving about Beautycounter’s new Countertime line, so I was eager to try it myself–and to give you guys my honest review. (Spoiler: of the three you see pictured there, I love two and don’t like one.)

beautycounter countertime question gimme the good stuff
I’ve received a lot of comments and questions like this one from you guys.

Are Beautycounter Anti-Aging Products Good Stuff?

Before I tell you how I feel about the performance of Beautycounter anti-aging skincare products, let’s discuss the safety. There’s always a concern that for products to really work–particularly anti-aging products–they can’t also be toxin-free.

In the case of Beautycounter products, they are, miraculously, both effective and safe. Beautycounter managed to find an alternative to retinol, which is definitely toxic but also undeniably effective, in the form of plant-based bakuchiol.

The Beautycounter anti-aging line contains some ingredients that I can’t call Good Stuff, like phenoxyethanol, and I wish they were organic. However, most of my readers who are my age (myself included!) are tempted to try traditional retinols or even Botox to fight aging skin, and Beautycounter has come up with an unquestionably safer option.

Beautycounter Anti-Aging Products I’ve Tried

Here is a list of what I’ve tried so far, and my honest assessment of each one.

1. I use this peel three nights a week. It really works as well as more expensive (including the more toxic) ones. I’ve been using this for months, and it is legitimately brightening and softening my skin. This one gets a thumb’s up.

Beautycounter Counter Overnight Resurfacing Peel from Gimme the Good Stuff

2. I recently started putting on this peptide cream on before sleep, too. I actually don’t use the cream on the nights I use the peel mentioned above, because I find that it doesn’t absorb as well when applied over the peel. There’s nothing I find more annoying than cream that kind of balls off when you rub your face afterwards.

Beautycounter Countertime Tetrapeptide Cream from Gimme the Good Stuff

3. I’ve also recently started using this eye cream, but it kind of does the rolling off thing mentioned above. I know some of you love it, though, so I’m going to keep using it to see if it helps with fine lines.

Beautycounter Countertime Renewal Eye Cream from Gimme the Good Stuff

My Honest Review of Other Beautycounter Products

In addition to the above Beautycounter anti-aging products, here are some other Beautycounter things I’ve tried, and whether I’d recommend them or not:

  1. Cleansing Balm. This was the first Beautycounter product I ever tried, and it lives up to the hype. Enthusiastic thumb’s up!
  2. Brightening Facial Mist. I’m not a fan of this one; it sits on my skin in an almost soapy way, rather than seeping in.
  3. Calendula Lip Conditioner. This little tub will last literally years, and it’s hands-down the best lip balm/gloss I’ve tried.
  4. Sheer Lipstick. This is my favorite lipstick, and I love the Twig color best of all.
  5. Lengthening Mascara. I love all the Beautycounter mascaras, but the lengthening formula is my favorite.
  6. Cream Cleanser. This is one of my favorite before-bed face cleanser, and it removes makeup quickly without any tight or dry sensation.
  7. Nourishing Day Cream. I don’t find this daily cream to absorb well, so I used up my bottle and then didn’t reorder.

Please comment below with which Beautycounter products you love (or hate!).

Stay sane,

Maia, Founder & CEO

Note: This article contains affiliate links or sponsored content, which means that if you make a purchase, we may earn a commission. We only recommend products that meet our strict standards for non-toxicity and that we use (or want to use!) ourselves. Thank you so much for supporting the brands that make Good Stuff! 

Enjoying this guide?

Join 60K families who rely on our free guides on everything from milk to mattresses! Sign up to get $5 off your first order, access to our ultimate Clean Products Cheat Sheet, and ongoing exclusive access to coupon codes and promotions. Our weekly newsletter is filled with well researched tips and tricks to live a toxin-free lifestyle.
Image showing various bar soaps. | Gimme The Good Stuff

The Best Natural Soap Guide 2024

Posted on
When it comes bar soap, the good news is that there are tons of safe options for organic soap. The bad news is that many of these soaps are difficult…

Safe Deodorant Guide

Posted on
The good news is that there are a ton of safe, natural deodorants to choose. They come in sticks, jars, roll-ons and sprays. And, yes, many of them actually work…

Safe Baby Wash & Soap Guide

Posted on
1. Babo Botanicals Sensitive Newborn Foam Wash / 2. MADE OF Foaming Organic Baby Wash  / 3. Carina Organics Baby Shampoo & Wash / 4. healthybaby Shampoo & Body Wash…
Kind Laundry Sheets from gimme the good stuff

22 Earth-Friendly Swaps for 2022

Posted on
One of my goals for 2022 is to up my Green game. My home doesn’t have many products with toxins in them (although I’m far from perfect), but I want…

Leave a Reply

  1. Alison Chapman Avatar
    Alison Chapman

    I started using BC when it first came out. I like the overnight resurfacing peel and calendula lip conditioner, too. I also use the cleansing balm for eye makeup because I got it free. It kind of bothers my eyes when it gets in them, and I’m concerned it will make me break out if I use it all over my face.
    Have used the rejuvenating night and eye cream for years and like it, and it’s not heavy, but just right. I also use the rejuvenating cleanser. I have the cream cleanser but I use it in the winter when it’s dryer with heat on. The rejuvenating one is my go to.
    I recently tried the whole regimen of natural retinols and it “balled up” at night and I also could not get my makeup on over it, even if I waited an hour, (and I don’t use that much makeup.) The whole routine was just too heavy and too time consuming, and I didn’t like the gunky feel from too much product, even though I used it conservatively.
    The cleanser in that line was probably a main culprit because it’s more of an oil, so I’d use it to remove makeup and then have to wash my face with another cleanser to feel clean. The night cream was so heavy that I felt like I’d break out, so I used it on my neck. My face just felt gunky overall, so I sent it back. If you have any thoughts on how to use part of that regimen without the “balling up,” I’d be interested.

  2. Grace Avatar

    Hi! I’m using retinol now and was wondering what toxicities it has. My impression was that if you’re not pregnant and never wear it out in the sun, it’s okay? Just wondered what you’ve dug up!


  3. Jane Avatar

    I have had my one tub of cleansing balm for 1.5 years and counting! Love it but it does irritate my eyes sometimes.